Tag Archives: Act of God to avoid responsibility for damages
Elks Lodge Hypocrites

My family moved to Ocala, FL in 2003 and bought a home in the Heritage Hills Subdivision next to a wooded area owned by the Ocala Elks Lodge at Northeast 25th Avenue, Ocala, FL 34470. Since 2004, we have suffered thousands of dollars in damages to our property from the Ocala Elks Lodge trees falling onto our property, while they used legal loopholes to evade paying for the damages.


While using motto’s such as ‘Elks Care, Elks Share‘ and claiming to be a Charitable, Caring, Benevolent organization, the Ocala Elks have REFUSED to take responsibility for damages caused by their trees to our property on several occasions.
Here’s the history of how the Ocala Elks Lodge has treated us, their neighbors…

The first tree from the Ocala Elks Lodge came down on our property during Hurricane Charley in August 2004 and damaged our fence. We notified the Elks Lodge about the damage and they eventually removed their tree and fixed our fence.
A few weeks later on Sunday, September 5, 2004 during Hurricane Frances, another Elks Lodge Tree came down and destroyed 100′ of the fence separating their property from ours causing $1,200 of damage.
I wrote to a Mr. Sid Carter who was an official at the lodge in Ocala and to their Exalted Ruler Mr Harold Floyd.
The response we received was a letter from their attorney, Mr. Daniel Hicks of Ocala who indicated that he represented the Elks Lodge and stated “The damages your complex suffered were a result of an “Act of God” and your insurance policy should cover your damages”.
Click to view a copy of the Elk’s attorney letter –
I was flabbergasted and outraged because he essentially told us the Ocala Elks Lodge had no intentions of doing anything about the damage caused by their trees. Our deductible was 1% which equals $1,370. out of pocket before our insurance paid one dime, which meant we would have had to pay for ALL of the damages out of our own pocket.
I think most people would agree that this was a despicable tactic for an organization which claims to be “Charitable”, “Caring” and “Benevolent” while publicly advertising aid to Florida Hurricane victims.

While the Elks here in Ocala, FL not only neglected, but refused to help their own neighbors who suffered damages from their trees, the Elks website was publicly advertising “Elks Pledges Aid to Florida Hurricane Victims”.
The Elks failure and refusal to do so is Hypocrisy Personified. This Elks Lodge’s claim of an “Act of God” to avoid responsibly is an OUTRAGE and proof that the Elks are Hypocrite who projects a public image of ‘doing good’ for communities, while being apathetic, stingy scrooges who doesn’t give a damn about their neighbors.
Any reasonable person would agree that the Elks should have rightfully paid for damage to our property, while advertising how they were “Pledging Aid to Florida Hurricane Victims“.
Photo of the Elks Lodge Headquarters in Chicago
After receiving the letter from the Ocala Elks attorney stating they were not going to do anything, I then wrote numerous officials within the Elks organization, including Mr. Jack Jensen Grand Secretary of the Elks National in Chicago, Elks USA Grand Lodge Headquarters in Chicago, Mr. Frank Palladini Florida Elks State President, Mr. James M. McQuillan, the Grand Exalted Ruler and the President of the Elks. On December 5, 2006 I sent letters to the Grand Exalted Ruler and President of the Elks, Mr. Louis James Grillo about this matter and received no reply.
NONE of these Elks Lodge members and management did anything to right the wrong which was done to my family.

On March 9, 2011 another large tree from the Elks property fell onto our property across our fence which had laid smashed and damaged since 2004 and also hit our garage.
This time, they had no hurricane or “Act of God” as an excuse defense… they had to pay for all the damages as they should have years ago.
It is important to note that when members of the Elks and their insurance adjuster came to see the damage caused by their tree in 2011, we showed them other trees on their property which were rotted and needed to be cut down.

In 2014, Karin (my better half) started the Whispurring Woods Cat Rescue, (a 501 c3 non-profit organization) and purchased a 30′ x 12′ building at a cost of almost $8,000. She even rescued cats from the Elks Lodge property. The above photo shows how the Whispurring Woods Cat Rescue Cabin looked before it was destroyed by another Elks tree on September 10, 2017.

September 10, 2017 – Photo of the Whispurring Woods Cat Rescue cabin; CRUSHED and Destroyed by a Huge Ocala Elks Lodge Tree, plus caused massive damage to our property and killed a beloved cat of Karin’s, owner of Whispurring Woods Kitty Rescue.
Early Sunday Morning of September 10, 2017 a Huge Elks Lodge Tree destroyed the Whispurring Woods Rescue Kitty Cabin and crushed about 150′ of our fence (the 4th time in 13 years the Elks Lodge Trees damaged our property). This almost caused Karin to have a heart attack, as you can hear in this heart-breaking video.

Karin, who started Whispurring Woods Cat Rescue in 2014, passed away on October 15, 2026 after suffering for a year from stage 4 rectal cancer. This has been a devastating loss for our family and 3 children.

The above article was published by WFTV Channel 9 about the damage. Click here to view article
Prior to the arrival of Hurricane Irma, we spent $3,000 to have trees in our back yard cut down to protect our home and the Cabin. We were therefore responsible property owners and did everything possible to protect our property.
9-29-17: I spoke with the Ocala Elks Lodge secretary this morning and he stated that they received the video and info about the damage caused by their tree and stated that they are only legally responsible for their tree on their side of the fence… essentially telling me they have no intentions of paying for any of the damage.
Our insurance has a $4,000 deductible which means WE have to pay that much out of our own pocket for their carelessness and neglect in maintaining their trees. That is not right, fair or just.

This One Flower is all that’s left of the Kitty Cabin

On 10/6/17, we paid $2,500 to have the Elks Tree, trees of ours which their tree destroyed, our destroyed cabin and all of the debris removed from our property. Not one cent offered from these people who’s motto is “Elks Care, Elks Share“.
You can see what’s left of their tree across our destroyed fence which caused all of the damage and a cat looking for it’s home. This Elks Lodge Tree caused MASSIVE DEVASTATION to our property.
Next, we had to pay about $2000 to have the fence repaired.
Since the Elks and their Insurance adjuster were notified about dangerous trees on the Elks property in 2011 which will fall & cause damage and the Elks has failed to cut the trees down and have done nothing to maintain their trees which border our fence in all of these years, I feel the Elks are guilty of “Willful Neglect“.
Willful Neglect Trumps “Act of God” claims to evade responsibility.
In my opinion, the Elks are in violation of their own Mission, Motto, Creed, Guidelines and have engaged in False Advertising and Hypocrisy.
Here’s proof…
As stated above in the National Elks Guidelines, they are supposed to provide “Assistance to People in Distress“. In our case the destruction caused by their trees CAUSED US DISTRESS and they gave us NO assistance.

The Elks Mission, Motto and Creed stated on the Elks.org website states…
“To inculcate the principles of Charity, Justice, Brotherly Love and Fidelity; to recognize a belief in God; to promote the welfare and enhance the happiness of its Members; to quicken the spirit of American patriotism; to cultivate good fellowship; to perpetuate itself as a fraternal organization, and to provide for its government, the Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks of the United States of America will serve the people and communities through benevolent programs, demonstrating that Elks Care and Elks Share“.
The definition of Benevolent is “an adjective that means marked by kindness, generosity, goodwill, or a desire to do good for others”
In our case, the Elks have proved that they are NOT Benevolent, do NOT care, do NOT share, have shown no Charity, Justice or Brotherly Love.
I think most people would also agree that it is JUST that since the Elks trees damaged our property, they should fix the damage.
The fact that NONE of the Elks I notified about this did anything is an OUTRAGE. Every member of the Elks who I notified and who failed to do anything has violated the Elks Mission, Motto and Creed, and they should be reprimanded and expelled as members.
The Ocala Elks Lodge has proven themselves to be Heartless, UN-caring, UN-sharing Hypocrites.
If average Joe good neighbors all over the state of Florida can accept responsibility for damage caused by trees to their neighbors property and repair the damage, the Elks who touts themselves as a philanthropic organization, should more than any neighbor in Florida do the right thing and remove their trees from our property and repair the damage.
The Elks Organization (National, Florida State & Local) has behaved in a disgraceful, stingy, selfish, UN-Brotherly, UN-Caring, apathetic manner by their failure to have the damage to our property repaired, which was caused by the Ocala Elks trees.
I suspect that many of the members of the Elks Lodge claim the be Christians who goes to church on Sunday. Jesus Christ teaches in the Gospels of Matthew 7:12 (from the Sermon on the Mount), “So in everything, do to others what you would have them do to you“. I think Ocala Elks Lodge management and members need to do some self reflection as to weather they are practicing Jesus Christ’s teaching… the 10 commandments which states “Love your neighbor as yourself“, how they have not practiced their own mission motto & creed, and how they have treated my family, who are their neighbors.

Hits: 2431

